The Watseka Wonder: The Double Life of Lurancy Venum
Mary Roff had died in July 1865 at the age of 18, having suffered from fits throughout her life. It now seemed to Roff that his daughter had returned from the grave and taken over Lurancy’s body. Indeed, Lurancy was giving every sign of being Mary Roff and was constantly pleading to be allowed to go home to her parents.

The Watseka Wonder – The Double Life of Lurancy Venum

Mary Lurancy Vennum was born in April 1864 in Milford, a small town near Watseka in eastern Illinois. She had an ordinary, remarkable childhood until she was 13. Then, in July 1877, she told her family: “There were persons in my room last night, and they called ‘Rancy! Rancy!’ and I felt their breath on my face.”

A few days later Laurancy had had a seizure, followed by another. She announced that she could see heaven, angels, and people who were now dead but whom she had known. Her distressed family anxiously sought medical advice and were grateful when their friends Mr. and Mrs. Roff recommended Dr. E. W. Stevens of Janesville, Wisconsin

A Disturbing Spirit

On January 3, 1878, Mr. Roff brought Stevens to the Vennums’ home. Lurancy had become increasingly disturbed and seemed to be having a continual inner struggle. With great difficulty Stevens calmed the girl down. She then told him that a spirit called Mary Roff exclaimed: “That is my daughter Mary Roff. Why? She has been in heaven 12 years. Yes, let her come; we’ll be glad to let her come.”

Mary Roff had died in July 1865 at the age of 18, having suffered from fits throughout her life. It now seemed to Roff that his daughter had returned from the grave and taken over Lurancy’s body. Indeed, Lurancy was giving every sign of being Mary Roff and was constantly pleading to be allowed to go home to her parents.
Roff Household

On February 11 “Mary Roff” moved to the Roff household. For three months she behave exactly as if she were the dead daughter of the Roffs’ immediately recognizing friends, relatives, clothes, and belongings. She also remembered scores of events from her past, many of which had occurred up to 25 years before. When the Vennums visited, “Mary Roff” behaved as if Lurancy reemerged.

On May 7 the personality of Lurancy reemerged. Sitting down again, and asked: “Where am I? I was never here before.” She pleaded to be taken home. But five minutes later the “Mary Roff” personality took control once more. Between May 7 and May 21 this temporary displacing of “Mary” by Lurancy occurred several times. Finally, “Mary” announced that it was time for Lurancy to return, and she said good-bye to her family and friends.
The Days of Full Possession

Lurancy was welcomed back into the bosom of her family, and she settled in happily. From time to time the “Mary” personality would emerge, but only briefly, and Lurancy was able to lead a normal life. The days of full possession seemed to be over.
The case of the Watseka Wonder, as Lurancy Vennum affair became known, came to attention of Dr. Richard Hodgson, a notoriously skeptical researcher into psychic phenomena. He studied it carefully in 1980 and concluded that there was no way that the strange case could be explained by any normal means. Either Mary Roff had returned from the dead to possess the body of Lurancy Vennum, or Lurancy had developed a secondary personality that used psychic powers to gather details about Mary Roff’s past life. The truth may never be known. The case of the Watseka Wonder retains its mystery to the present day.
Liked it
18 Comments
ken bultman, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
I love a mystery.
Shirley Shuler, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
A very interesting post indeed!
Jamie Myles, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
What an unusual story. Very interesting .I like it.
CHAN LEE PENG, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
interesting read dude..unique one of course, keep it up!
John, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
Love the article.
wonder, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
An intriguing story, keep it up.
Momof4, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
A great article of an interesting story. Well done. Thanks for sharing. I liked it.
Naomi
Idazalee, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
Another great mystery story. Well-researched article and very interesting read as usual. Thanks for sharing
Christine Ramsay, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
A very strange but interesting story.
Christine
martie, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
very bizarre. Good telling of the story.
MMV Abad, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
Interesting post. Thank you friend.
papaleng, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
bizzarre story that is well presented. keep up the good work Mr. Ghaz, CHEERS!!!
Sherry Wallace, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
Very interesting, mrghaz!
Lostash, posted this comment on Oct 6th, 2009
Fantastic mystery! There is still so much we do not understand.
martinpm, posted this comment on Oct 8th, 2009
very interesting!! liked your article
David A. Mitchell, posted this comment on Oct 8th, 2009
Here is a story uncovered from the Friday, Dec. 7, 1951, edition of the Iroquois County Times:
Report Movie May
Be Made On Play,
‘Watseka Wonder’
One of Watseka’s oldest and
most famous mysteries is going
Hollywood!
The mystery, developed in a
recent play by Patrick Mahoney
which he calls “Watseka Wonder,”
involves a 14-year-old girl named
Lurancy Vennum who lived with
her parrents in Watseka in 1887.
According to Hedda Hopper, Hol-
lywood columnist, 20th Century
Fox studio is seeking an option to
the play for a movie to star Mar-
garet O’Brien.
According to the tale, which has
been investigated by noted philos-
ophers in the past, Lurancy Ven-
num adopted the personality of an-
other girl named Mary Roff, who
had died in Watseka 12 years be-
fore.
She went to live with the Roff
family in a house which then was
located on the corner of Oak and
Fourth streets. A large, 12-room
frame building, it was razed about
20 years ago.
Lurancy Vennum was found to
have knowledge of the Roff girl’s
entire history, including every
memory which the dead girl might
be expected to possess.
She led the life of Mary Roff,
claiming the dead girl had claimed
her body, for 15 weeks before she
herself died. During those weeks,
according to past articles written
about the case, Lurancy Vennum’s
memory, attitudes and mannerisms
were those of the dead Roff girl.
How such a transition could
take place has never been satis-
factorily explained, but the story
continues to live. Mahoney’s play
recently was shown in the Pasa-
dena playhouse in California.
hollynoel001, posted this comment on Oct 9th, 2009
very interesting article great mystery to do more research on!!













ceegirl, posted this comment on Oct 5th, 2009
Good information, thanks fo sharing.