The Extraordinary Anti-Nazi Photomontages of John Heartfield

The Extraordinary Anti-Nazi Photomontages of John Heartfield

How the photomontage art of John Heartfield, a contemporary and friend of Brecht, warned the world of the rise of Hitler and Nazism. In the fight against sophisticated Nazi propaganda, Heartfield showed the Nazi regime in its true light.

Image Credit

In the 1930s the Nazis were gaining ground in Europe.  Many chose to ignore or had a laissez faire attitude to the National Socialist policy of expansionism, known as Lebensraum or the threat of war that Germany now posed to the world.  John Heartfield (above center, in 1960), a German citizen, was one who chose to criticize the regime through art and he produced a remarkable series of photomongages, the audacity of which still has the capacity to astonishe today.

Blood and Iron

Image Credit

Bismarck had stated that the German people would be reformed through a combination of blood and iron.  Heartfield’s 1939 photomontage shows exactly how this was to be interpreted in reality.  Heartfield had always been a reactionary when it came to German nationalism.  Born in 1891 as Helmut Herzfeld he saw the horrors of the First World War first hand.  Although propaganda was rife and rabid on both sides he made the extraordinary move of anglicizing his name in 1916, in the middle of the war, to protest against such nationalism.

Kaiser Adolf

Image Credit

The real motive for Hitler’s stranglehold on political power in the thirties was something that was utterly transparent to Heartfield.  Here, he gives Hitler the Emperor’s old clothes and upturned moustache to reveal that power had simply changed hands and nothing had changed in democratic terms.  As a left wing socialist, Heartfield was diametrically opposed to the right wing National Socialism (Nazism) that swept Germany.  It was after founding a satirical magazine, Die Pleite, that he met Brecht.  Later he would work for the weekly AIZ (published in exile, of course, this sort of thing would never have been allowed inside The Fatherland).  It was for AIZ that he produced most of his photomontage work.

Hitler Prepares to Kill the French Cockerel

Image Credit

Although some of his work may seem a little primitive in our days of Photoshop, the meaning of Heartfield’s 1939 work is as sharp as the knife that the dictator is holding.  The caption jokes ironically around Hitler’s vegetarianism.  Vegetarians, although around in the thirties, were considered somewhat odd by the general population. The French Foreign Minister is seen to be unperturbed at the sharpening of knives.  After all, Herr Hitler did not eat meat.  Of course, by this time, Heartfield had had to remove himself from Germany at the beginning of the Nazi Regime as this sort of political satire would no doubt have earned him a visit in the night and a trip to a concentration camp.  He left Germany in 1933, the year Hitler came to power and relocated to nearby Czechoslovakia.

The Butter is Gone

Image Credit

As the caption on the card says, this is bitterly satirical and based on the words of Göring in 1935.  Hermann Göring, on of the potentates of Nazi Germany, said, during a food shortage that “Iron has always made a nation strong, butter and lard have only made the people fat”.  If one of our politicians were to say that today there would probably be a riot but satire like this was one of the few ways to injure the regime.  Possibly Heartfield’s most famous work, this family attempts to eat the various weapons of war that have been built instead of the butter that should have been on their table.  The swastika wallpaper in the background is a particularly deft touch and shows how the regime permeated all aspects of even domestic life.

The German Oak Tree

Image Credit

The Oak Tree is watered by the environmentally aware Hitler.  However, what it produces is shells and iron helmets marked with swastikas.  A potent image showing how the ideals of a nation will water down from the top, the oak tree is Germany – watered from the bottom by the man at the top.  This was produced in 1939 by which time Heartfield had felt it necessary to retreat from his adopted host nation of Czechoslovakia.  He made it to England and lived in Hampstead, London, for the duration of the war.

The Middle Ages and the Third Reich

Image Credit

With reference to the medieval torture instrument, the Wheel, Heartfield skillfully adapts the swastika (itself an image accosted and misused by the Nazis) to picture what was happening to the German people under the ‘guidance’ of Adolf Hitler and his cronies.  Some might say that this image of suffering is somewhat generous to the German people, portraying them as the victims of Nazism but once Hitler had secured absolute power for himself and with no way of democratically – or governmentally – relieving him of his position (as was the case with Mussolini in Italy) then victims is exactly what they were. 

The House That Hitler Built

Image Credit

The house of cards that was bound to topple, the political system of Germany is shown here.  Prescient as ever, Heartfield shows Hitler as the drummer boy at the base of the pack of cards.  At the top is the industrialist, Thyssen, showing how industry colluded with the dictator.  The weight of the Nazi flag at the top is just too much for the house of cards to stand and it is seen just before it collapses.  As would be the case in Europe, Nazism was built on foundations that would never last for too long – it was a political system that was bound, at some point, to collapse.

Peace and Fascism

Image Credit

This is a particularly brutal piece of satire – the dove of peace is often shown dead or dying but here it is transfixed – literally – on a bayonet, representing the rise of fascism in Europe in the 1930s.  The League of Nations building is shown in the background.  Peer closely and you will see the swastika flying from it.  This shows the bitterness, felt by many that the nascent organization founded to represent the nations of the world in the aftermath of the First World War had failed in its duty.  In its ineffective manner it had, in fact, encouraged the rise of Nazism and Fascism on the beleaguered continent of Europe.

Aftermath

Image Credit

After the defeat of Hitler and Nazism, Heartfield returned to Germany and lived out the rest of his days Germany and East Berlin.  His life and works were commemorated on a postage stamp.  During the later years he worked closely with a variety of theater directors and in 1967 he visited London to prepare for a retrospective of his work.  Unfortunately he died before this happened, but his widow completed the work for the exhibition and it was shown at the ICA in 1969.  Although the Tate Modern in London did a retrospective of his work a few years ago, he remains a little known artist.  Perhaps this short piece will help to put that right.

156
Liked it

40 Comments

C Jordan, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

A clever use of art to make a political statement
I was not awatre of this artist, thanks RJ

Glynis Smy, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

I ditto Chris. I had not seen any of these before nor had I heard of the artist. The butter one is my ‘favourite’. Thanks for a quality read. Thumbs up.

Juancav, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Creative anti-nazi advises,well researched.

Joe Dorish, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Had not heard of John Heartfield before this article either but like his work. Thanks for this and Thumbs Up from me too.

Rana Sinha, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Great article RJ. I wonder what he would have thought of the world now!

CHAN LEE PENG, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

I found the pictures very funny especially the sixth one. I haven’t heard this man, John Heartfield before, but I think he was such a clever man “to soap” a political motive.

Judy T Lloyd, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Extraordinary warnings. Perhaps we should pay more attention to art.

Briana, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Those are powerful statements and they still make an impact. More of his artwork at http://www.towson.edu/heartfield/artarchive.html

Anne McNew, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

I found again another great article of yours RJ. very informative.

Lisa Clayton Williams, posted this comment on May 10th, 2009

Interesting article!

Bill M. Tracer, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Well written, R. J.

An artist well worth the attention you give.

frank horton, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

it is not well known but there was an entire generation of German artists and news paper men that saw the danger of Herr Hitler and tried to warn against the danger on the future horizon. the real wonder is mister Heartfield was not killed with the rest. Amazing and wonderful that his art survived those years.

Will @ A Journey Round My Skull, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Great stuff.

This book needs to be reprinted:

http://ajourneyroundmyskull.blogspot.com/2008/06/kurt-tucholsky-deutschland-deutschland.html

It includes many collages by Heartfield.

Manduh, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

never heard of this artist until now. thank you. i love what these pieces show, it explains so much without having to speak a word.

Andrew, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

For those interested, MOMA held a retrospective in 1993, which I was lucky enough to see. Afterwards I purchased the large format book that accompanied the exhibition. It’s full of dozens of images, and 8 or 9 essays. The books details are:

John Heartfield
Harry N Abrams, Inc Publishers
New York
1992
ISBN 0 8109 3413 2

twopenneth, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

a very informative post. thank you for this rj. here in the netherlands, the nazi really left an ugly mark but fortunately the dutch doesnt hate the germans that much anymore

Betty Carew, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Awesome article RJ I really enjoyed reading this.

s hayes, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Wow ! stunning images – great article

charlotter789, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

very intresting

Mark Bentley, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Wow, some really interesting images. Well ahead of his time.

I have also added this to Reddit for you.

iflajsig, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Verry sad…correct statement of the artist would nopt change the history, verry verry sad….

John Brown, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Thank you for this very interesting piece. Had the pleasure of citing it in my “Public Diplomacy Press and Blog Review.”
http://publicdiplomacypressandblogreview.blogspot.com/2009/05/may-11.html

Ray Trygstad, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Very powerful and perceptive art. A pity he could not recognize that ANY regime that suppresses freedom of thought and speech is evil–i.e. the DDR.

Paola Hernandez, posted this comment on May 11th, 2009

Wonderful art It’s amazing the talent of an artist and what he can transmit

t simon, posted this comment on May 12th, 2009

a very impressive collection. It makes me think how adversity can bring out the best in gifted artists.

Rajiv Sighamony, posted this comment on May 12th, 2009

In fact, I never heard about John heartfield and his art. thanks for letting me know.

Mr Ghaz, posted this comment on May 12th, 2009

Fantastic! ..thats really amaze me..Great post!..wonderful and well presented article about Anti-Nazi..LOV it..a must read article..well done and thanx for sharing

Patrick Bernauw, posted this comment on May 12th, 2009

This was completely new to me! Great job!

mcdaidusa, posted this comment on May 13th, 2009

I hope to live long enough to see the same commemoration of artists in America that opposed Bush and Co. and held-off the conversion of the USA into a fascist state. Green Day’s “American Idiot” comes to mind, though there are so many others….

kourosh, posted this comment on May 13th, 2009

very good image!!!!!!

hiho, posted this comment on May 15th, 2009

I’ll always remember two explicit but true-life images that would probably be censored here: (1) A man in Auschwitz who had been shot on a barbed wire fence and was left to hang there; (2) A mass grave at Bergen-Belsen…thankyou for posting this wonderful article about a German man who opposed Hitler and his murderous regime.

natalie, posted this comment on May 15th, 2009

brilliant, and way better than photoshop

amin, posted this comment on May 16th, 2009

ابروی هیتلر رو بردند
همه لشکریان از ان خداوند هستند.

Mama Heartfilled, posted this comment on May 16th, 2009

Very interesting view of Hitler’s evil!

CutestPrincess, posted this comment on Jun 3rd, 2009

the author always published satisfying article… excellent!

Mark Gordon Brown, posted this comment on Jun 5th, 2009

Always a shame when a great artist is only valued too late.

B Nelson, posted this comment on Jun 5th, 2009

Awesome link R J! This guy was ahead of his time

Anonymous, posted this comment on Jun 7th, 2009

Obviousy shopped.

Emma C S, posted this comment on Jun 15th, 2009

Those are great! I love this kind of thing… subverting old pictures into something new and clever, but looks like this guy was in there way before Banksy and his like.

Leonardo davinci Evans, posted this comment on Oct 12th, 2009

Obviously you are writing about a hero to life. I’m glad he was able to live a full life…so many hero’s of that time did not. You are a special person yourself for keeping the memory alive.

Leave a Response